Mt. Lebanon was the deserving winner last year and had a talented, well-coached, and balanced team.
From an SJP perspective, the fact that Heard played only sparingly (because of injury) really hurt their defense. But what sticks out most for me was the call at the very end of the first half when, down by 7, the coach decided to try a field goal from the two or three yard line when the kicker was kicking at the left hash mark and the wind was swirling. Chadha was an excellent place-kicker--as he showed in the second half--but the decision to go for a very difficult fg which, if made, would still leave SJP down by four at the half, rather than for a td, which was probably, like a two point extra point attempt, about a 50-50 chance but which would have tied the game and given SJP a big boost after being down 14, was an unusually bad one by Roken.
Also, unlike others, I think this year's SJP team (with Trotter, Dumond, Niles, McMahon, Garwood, Cervantes, Doyle, Ditrolio, and Woods playing big roles as seniors) could be as good as next year's.