Very bold of you to assume football will exist in twenty yearsWhen you see what is going on you realize that the PIAA and high school football in the Keystone State has got to take some kind of steps to open things up or just stand back and watch the sport as it winds down across the Commonwealth. Sure, there will be the St. Joe's and PCCs and Erie Cathedrals, etc. but as a whole the public side will kind of just disappear. Kind of just a glorified "flag football" - maybe make it co-ed (that would be fun - wear soft pads and won't need helmets). Go to 8 classes to make more "state championships" available (inclusion is important).
Leave "Big Boy" football to states like CA, AZ, Texas, LA, FLA, GA -- states where it matters.
Then when we want to get the blood flowing we can visit the good PA high school sites and read about the old days (when it mattered). Rover's and stalker's great writings and works can have us reliving the glory days over and over (at least in our heads)
The landscape is changing, for sure. Just imagine another twenty years from now when high school football players in the big states are getting big bucks for endorsements. You wonder how many families will make arrangements to have their star boys find their way into that mix (they're sure as heck not gonna hang around upstate PA playing for the local high school).
Changing in a hurry (and PA better get with it -- or just call it a day).
Stalk- thanks for the insight- very interesting from the Florida perspectiveI imagine the popularity of FB is dropping everywhere except perhaps in the deep south (Al, La, Miss, etc). It is not what it was 10 years ago even in Florida, fortunate as I am to have had relatives at 4 title teams; Lakeland, Dwyer-West Palm, Manatee-Bradenton, Frostproof. Having said that, parts of Florida are still 'deep south'. These are mostly designated S (Suburban) or R (rural) in playoff designations, formally divisions.
Everything is different in Florida now with teams broken down to Metro (8 most dense counties), Suburban (59 other counties), Rural (8 to 9 rural schools) meaning very rural as in the Panhandle (south Alabama as we call it) and very north Fl towns on Ga border west of Jax; Okefenokee Swamp/Osceola Wildlife area.
Lakeland won it again last year (21-14 Venice) to a crowd maybe a little larger than Cumberland Valley or typical Hershey Pk Stad numbers. Check out the crowd size or google that game and score if it doesn't open. Not their best but not a bad team.
lakeland 21-14 venice - Google Search
www.google.com
You're welcome 2020. I think Florida ball is sometimes misrepresented (all is well, no problems, etc) with justification if that makes any sense as it is so good; speed, size, dedication to the sport. But they share similar if not same issues we have in Pa. Still, I don't think FB is on the way out unless hockey replaces it or some form of roller ball as we still love to bash each other. We're not all made to be soccer dudes, tho you can have some fun there too!Stalk- thanks for the insight- very interesting from the Florida perspective
PSU has PA lineman (IMG 2 yrs ago) on the roster. Last year Pennridge lost a LB to IMG and this year North Penn is losing a center. The new head coach has PA ties. What many dont know is IMG is a international boarding school for the wealthy, tuition is well over 100k a year. High academics all interwoven into ALL sports. They just dont have a national team, they have 2 varsity teams and a post grad team. The national team players are on full scholarship. Thier varsity teams would give PA teams a run for thier money and probably be favored. So I think that you'll see more players making the commitment to play at a higher level.... SNOWBALL EFFECT. As far as Singleton, there's always going to be a freak athlete popping up every now and then. The problem PA has is not the caliber of athletes, it's football IQ that PA is falling behind on. Colleges don't have time to teach football, they want you to know the game when you get there. PA used to be one of the big 3 states in recruiting... I don't thinkThe IMG thing is crazy and interesting, but i do not see it affecting things much in PA. Sadly, the locals with any power and influence just don't care enough about football being "big." And- honestly- I think football will "stay around." When that concussion movie came out people said "football was over" but that was 8 years ago- maybe football in PA is not what it was 30 years ago, but it is still popular, kids play, and parents support it enough to keep it going.
The IMG thing- to me, only a big deal for "4 stars and 5 stars" throughout the country and PA does not have many of those. Also- only one- but a good example of a big-time recruit and "success in PA" is Nick Singleton. Played in PA, trained in his local gym, and starring at PSU!!! Very likely to play on Sundays and do well.
PSU has PA lineman (IMG 2 yrs ago) on the roster. Last year Pennridge lost a LB to IMG and this year North Penn is losing a center. The new head coach has PA ties. What many dont know is IMG is a international boarding school for the wealthy, tuition is well over 100k a year. High academics all interwoven into ALL sports. They just dont have a national team, they have 2 varsity teams and a post grad team. The national team players are on full scholarship. Thier varsity teams would give PA teams a run for thier money and probably be favored. So I think that you'll see more players making the commitment to play at a higher level.... SNOWBALL EFFECT. As far as Singleton, there's always going to be a freak athlete popping up every now and then. The problem PA has is not the caliber of athletes, it's football IQ that PA is falling behind on. Colleges don't have time to teach football, they want you to know the game when you get there. PA used to be one of the big 3 states in recruiting... I don't think we're even top ten.
I am sure the top states here are the big producers in general.but I believe many 5 stars .are over rated and end up transfering due to not making the grade at the next level. On a related note, how many scholarship OFFERS are permitted to be given in a given year by schools ? I have heard that some offer 200 plus athletes in a year,but can only acceot about 25 or so. This seems to be awatered down process to me. Any thoughts ?
Division Level | Number of Teams | Total Athletes in Division | Average Team Size | Scholarships Limit Per Team | Scholarship Limit Type |
D1 – FBS | 129 | 15,167 | 118 | 85 | Headcount |
D1 – FCS | 125 | 13,028 | 104 | 63 | Equivalency |
D2 | 170 | 18,889 | 111 | 36 | Equivalency |
D3 | 248 | 25,709 | 104 | N/A | N/A |
NAIA | 85 | 9,102 | 107 | 24 | Equivalency |
JUCO | 68 | 5,160 | 76 | 85 | Equivalency |
CCCAA | 68 | 5,354 | 79 | N/A | Equivalency |
I am sure the top states here are the big producers in general.but I believe many 5 stars .are over rated and end up transfering due to not making the grade at the next level. On a related note, how many scholarship OFFERS are permitted to be given in a given year by schools ? I have heard that some offer 200 plus athletes in a year,but can only acceot about 25 or so. This seems to be awatered down process to me. Any thoughts ?
That is the situation I was referencing. If a player receives an offer is it really an offer . If I received an offer and wanted to commit and was then told well wait we have to see if we get anyone better ,I would strike that school off my list for sure.Very few are commitable offers. A lot of kids are in the dark about thier offer. Schools shouldn't be able to offer everyone in the country. PSU 357 Bama 191... I guess Saban is a little more selective.
If my memory is correct the limiting of scholarships was referred to as the "Johnny Majors Rule".Interestingly prior to 1973 schools could hand out whatever number they wanted for D1 and then because of Title X or whatever it was limited that year for the first time to 105 (make room for the ladies). It has been down sized since then to 95 (in the '80s I think) and then 85 sometime thereafter.
Next, and who cares about anyone's personal story, but I graduated from high school in 1972 and did secure a "full ride" at a major Southern school. As I recall there were a load of freshmen who showed up for the 1972 season with a football scholarship - like 70 or some crazy number (any notions about how good I was were quickly dispelled as most of the kids were Southerners and they dug football - and were tough as nails and good).
We were all under the assumption that the schools were (1) loading up to prevent talent from going to other schools and/or that (2) eventually the high number that showed up would be run off or be injured enough anyway to call it a day - so who cared how many "rides" were handed out as the numbers dwindled (for instance, we played Alabama and the rumor was most assuredly that Bryant was doing that).
It was a different world back then - that's for sure (and I did make it through all the way but mostly spent my time dressed in other's teams colors or on an operating table getting the latest orthopedic injury squared away - ha).
Note: If I had a son I would have advised tennis or baseball.
I talk to college coaches everyday. Trust me when I say that outside of playing QB, I've never heard this brought up once in the past 20 years.The problem PA has is not the caliber of athletes, it's football IQ that PA is falling behind on. Colleges don't have time to teach football, they want you to know the game when you get there.
It's called population loss18th .... PA used to be one of the top states.
I coached in Maryland and Delaware. I knew several PA guys in those states. But, none of them left PA to coach in those states. They left because PA used to have huge surplus of teachers. You struggled to find a teaching job in PA 15 years ago.The problem with PA is that some
Of your best coaches are not in PA. Since there are no teaching jobs that goes with these coaching jobs in PA good young coaches leave or have left the state.
"Population loss"...There's plenty of less populated states that are above PA... the numbers say so. "Outside of playing QB"... so PA doesn't have QB coaches? You've admitted that coaches left, but that doesn't effect football IQ? Go back and ask those coaches why we're seeing the numbers slip? What do you think theyre going to insult the local coaches? There's no rational that you can think of that says why one coach can dominate a league every year and other teams in that league dont even come close. Explain why the same teams players are getting the scholarships or grant in aid money. Its because theyre college ready. We may have different opinions, but PA football has fallen off and that's a fact we both agree on.I talk to college coaches everyday. Trust me when I say that outside of playing QB, I've never heard this brought up once in the past 20 years.
It's called population loss
PA has never lost population. It’s just changed and is still changing. PA has about 12 million people but hasn’t grown as much as CA, TX, FL and some other states. PA demographics have changed too. Compare us to OH and you’ll be surprised. PA was a dominant blue collar state; not so much anymore. Western PA population has migrated a bit east which helped the areas outside of Philly in the 70’s along with the suburbia sprawl and flight of Philly. Moleskinner can tell you about the 70’s powerhouses in his neck of the woods. Upper bucks was tiny until the last 30 years. Where I live was the sticks, why I guess they have new high schools. Philly peaked prior to the 70’s and had almost all the talent - speed and size and it wasn’t SJP. Philly, although growing recently, lost about 500,000 from their peaks. Pittsburgh is only about 400,000. Dougherty was the largest Catholic school in the country. West Philly and Frankford teams had incredible talent and size. Western PA was devastated in the 70’s, like the country as a whole - we were changing rapidly out of industries where the rest of the world caught up after being devastated in wwii. Many of these families moved down to some of what was left in South Eastern PA. Lehigh Valley has changed too. I’m retired now but travel, lots of PA too and see the big changes in populations and industries but also note that PA has also changed in other ways. When we were young players Football was king in PA, it’s still important but there are other options and considerably more professional families persuading their boys to play other sports besides football. There’s also this extreme attitude to succeed at all costs that has entered into high school football. Ask a current coach of the average IQ or responsibilities of the average football players or coach compared to 30 years ago (old timers). Also, the idea of joining another school system to play football that wasn’t local to win and or more exposure wasn’t even entertained. These are our times. Lots has changed the last 30 plus years, PA high school football is no different. One thing you can count on in life is change. For me, ill keep watching my local teams as it’s still my favorite entertainment. 😀I talk to college coaches everyday. Trust me when I say that outside of playing QB, I've never heard this brought up once in the past 20 years.
It's called population loss
Sure it has. Some regions like you've said have lost much more then others. As a state we rank near the bottom in terms of population growth.PA has never lost population.
Are you talking about talent when it comes to eastern PA or the state when saying Philly had almost all the talent? Pittsburgh and Western PA still was very much a different animal when it came to recruiting up and through the 90's.Philly peaked prior to the 70’s and had almost all the talent - speed and size and it wasn’t SJP.
Western PA families migrated to Southeastern PA during this time? Most of my western PA family and families alike migrated south to places like Florida, Texas, Georgia, etc.. I grew up in central PA and the majority of families I knew migrated into that area from Maryland and DC because the real estate was so cheap. Most of them worked in Maryland and lived in PA.Western PA was devastated in the 70’s, like the country as a whole - we were changing rapidly out of industries where the rest of the world caught up after being devastated in wwii. Many of these families moved down to some of what was left in South Eastern PA
In Western PA most of the large schools have a fraction of the graduating class size that they did in 1960's and 1970's.Dougherty was the largest Catholic school in the country. West Philly and Frankford teams had incredible talent and size.
"I grew up in central PA and the majority of families I knew migrated into that area from Maryland and DC because the real estate was so cheap. Most of them worked in Maryland and lived in PA."Sure it has. Some regions like you've said have lost much more then others. As a state we rank near the bottom in terms of population growth.
When I used to coach in Maryland, James Franklin stated the obvious that for PSU, the state of PA is not the priority it once was. For PSU the move DMV recruiting started at the end of the Paterno regime. Franklin said they have to dominate the DMV to be relevant in the B10 because PA can't support PSU the way it used to.
It's no coincidence that where the population density is the highest, the talent pool increases.
When Andy Urbanic was at FSU I spoke to him about recruiting and he said in 1975, the southern schools constantly recruited the north. What happened was the mills closed and those folks left. Many of my coaching buddies are in Florida. Many of them had family who were PA residents in the 1950's, 1960's, 1970's...
Are you talking about talent when it comes to eastern PA or the state when saying Philly had almost all the talent? Pittsburgh and Western PA still was very much a different animal when it came to recruiting up and through the 90's.
Western PA families migrated to Southeastern PA during this time? Most of my western PA family and families alike migrated south to places like Florida, Texas, Georgia, etc.. I grew up in central PA and the majority of families I knew migrated into that area from Maryland and DC because the real estate was so cheap. Most of them worked in Maryland and lived in PA.
In Western PA most of the large schools have a fraction of the graduating class size that they did in 1960's and 1970's.
It blows my mind that people will commute from York/Adams to Baltimore and DC. My mom commuted from York to Baltimore for 35 years. I know without traffic, you can do it in 45 minutes but you can be on 83/695 for an hour and 1/2 depending on the day and time. I can't imagine doing the DC commute. The traffic around DC is for the birds!"I grew up in central PA and the majority of families I knew migrated into that area from Maryland and DC because the real estate was so cheap. Most of them worked in Maryland and lived in PA."
That's still the case Steel where I'm from (Gburg, Adams cty) with DC-MD crowd (Mason-Dixon 10 miles south) moving to Fairfield-Gburg area for cheaper land. And, many farms have been sold with the upcoming generation not following in footsteps. So Cent PA has always had appeal to us natives and now unfortunately to others. Some of the vistas etc in Fairfield-Carrolls Valley area aren't there anymore, replaced by a large expensive home where once you came down the mountains around a winding curve from the orchards and had a wonderful view. I get it but don't have to like it.
It's the same in parts of Florida where half my family lives, resenting the flood of people into the Jupiter-West Palm area tho realizing in some ways it's good for business. But not for traffic with my son and 2 other families moving north to Palm City/Stewart.
"Population loss"...There's plenty of less populated states that are above PA... the numbers say so.
We have some of the best QB coaches in the country."Outside of playing QB"... so PA doesn't have QB coaches? You've admitted that coaches left, but that doesn't effect football IQ?
I am a coach.Go back and ask those coaches why we're seeing the numbers slip? What do you think theyre going to insult the local coaches? There's no rational that you can think of that says why one coach can dominate a league every year and other teams in that league dont even come close.
Explain why the same teams players are getting the scholarships or grant in aid money. Its because theyre college ready. We may have different opinions, but PA football has fallen off and that's a fact we both agree on.
I know coaches also. One thing you left out on why coaches leave the HS game. They're very aware of how hard they're allowed to coach. Take Pine Richland for example... it only takes one kid or parent that wants to make an issue and the program/ coach is made a target of the school board. Another school CB West coach taken down by one kid and his parents. You brought up SJP... they don't have the same problem because the students are there by choice and expect to be coached hard. Hats off to you for coaching but the quality of coaching has fallen off. For example Pennsbury has been terrible until the previous retired coach couldn't stand it anymore and came back to coach. Worst to first his first year back.We have some of the best QB coaches in the country.
We have some of the best training outlets for kids to get better.
It has nothing to do with coaching IQ or player IQ. That's completely bunk.
I am a coach.
The college coaches all tell me the #1 factor in finding talent in numbers is population density.
The DMV is the closest hotbed that produces the highest end talent around here. The amount of people that live that small area is ridiculous.
The DMV is 6th largest metropolis in the USA. Philly is #7. There is no coincidence they produce the highest quantity in football talent.
The reason SJP dominates is they value football and they have access to the highest # of population in the state. The same can be said for Imhotep.
Do the same schools year after year get the same type of money? Let's take the non boundary schools out of the mix and answer that question. 15 years ago Woodland Hills produced year in and year out more talent then anyone in the state. They were a 4A program in a 4 class system. now they're a 3A school in a 6 class system. hmm..
You guys are both correct. Population loss in western PA and also "population density" are both big factors. Pa football is still good, just not as great nationally as it used to be. Also, Wilson you are correct, coaches leave, or don't even START coaching because of the lack of support- off the top of my head in the last 20 years, i recall very good coaches who were, or "almost" pushed out at Aliquippa, North Hills, PR, McKeesport. All places that "support football." idk, maybe overall, coaching is just as good as it used to be, it's just differentI know coaches also. One thing you left out on why coaches leave the HS game. They're very aware of how hard they're allowed to coach. Take Pine Richland for example... it only takes one kid or parent that wants to make an issue and the program/ coach is made a target of the school board. Another school CB West coach taken down by one kid and his parents. You brought up SJP... they don't have the same problem because the students are there by choice and expect to be coached hard. Hats off to you for coaching but the quality of coaching has fallen off. For example Pennsbury has been terrible until the previous retired coach couldn't stand it anymore and came back to coach. Worst to first his first year back.