SJP would never not allow their students from Jersey to participate in any school activity, including sports. The school has had a substantial number of students from Jersey since the Benjamin Franklin Bridge was built in 1926--and maybe before!!! I know some other PCL schools have occasionally had students from Jersey, but never in numbers close to what SJP has had. That's partly because of location. (It's easier to get to SJP from Cherry Hill, Mount Laurel, Haddonfield, etc. than from parts of NE Philly, much of Delaware, Montgomery, or all of Bucks County.) It's also because many students/families are quite willing to travel past 5-50 high schools to get to SJP.I agree, which is again why I’m not advocating for it. It’s the one reasonable compromise I can see.
So if the PIAA put in a rule barring out-of-state players from the playoffs, the Prep would be out. The question is what the rest of the PCL would do. My guess is they'd say "If the Prep goes, we'll all go," but maybe I'm wrong.
One thing to note is that though SJP has basketball, baseball, soccer, etc. players from Jersey, it's only football where there seems to be an issue. So the "no out of state players" rule used to solve a perceived problem in only one sport would apply to a whole bunch of sports.
Just wondering if SJP doesn't not win the state football championship next year if the whole topic dies. Also wondering if the Mount Lebanon people are wishing they had played (and beaten) another team in the title game.
Stalker, thanks for listing all those schools. I agree it helps illustrate the problem but not an obvious solution.
SJP may have great teams for many more years, but it is far from a given. Several things could happen--at least a few of which did happen or almost happened last year--to make state championships games something other than par for the course.