Since I'm tired of reading arguments about recruiting, private schools, and who lives where, let's get at each other's throats about football again. After the state championships, I started doing some research to put this together. Local newspaper coverage and MaxPreps helped a lot with stats and narrative. When in doubt, good players on great teams got ephemeral bonus points. The roster construction is the same as the AP All State teams the past two years in terms of positions and numbers at each. I did add one category, jumbo athletes, because the OL/DL types get overlooked in a sea of skill players. Here it is:
Quarterbacks
Ben DiNucci, Pine-Richland: 278-401, 4,269 yards, 46 TDs - 9 INTs
Kyle Schurmur, LaSalle: 200-312, 2,523 yards, 28 TDs
Jordan Young, Coatesville: 208-324, 2,270 yards, 20 TDs - 8 INTs / 147 carries for 669 yards, 21 TDs
Stellar season by DiNucci, who should walk away with just about every state player of the year award after setting the all class single season yards record. Schurmur led the always explosive LaSalle passing attack and was third in the state in all passing categories at the end of his season (finished 6th in yards and TDs). Young was the only player in the state with 20 TDs passing and rushing.
HM: Brandon McIlwain, Council Rock North; Gabe French, DuBois; Devante Cross, Parkland; Kevin Caldwell, Benjamin Franklin; Tyler McNulty, Downingtown West; Brent Laffoon, Pen-Trafford
Running Backs
Charles Snorweah, Pennsbury: 313 carries for 2,780 yards, 38 TDs
Terry Loper, WC Rustin: 235 carries for 2,227 yards, 27 TDs.
Gerald Douglas, Stroudsburg: 256 carries for 1,916 yards, 23 TDs
Jake McCarthy, Scranton: 171 carries for 1,730 yards, 26 TDs / 30 total TDs
Snorweah led the state in rushing by over 500 yards and was a one man band in the playoffs for Pennsbury. Loper also put up a 2,000 yard season out of the Wing-T. Douglas was the state's leading rusher in the regular season and carried the offensive load for a 10-1 Stroudsburg team. McCarthy was the only back in the state to average over 200 yards per game, and despite breaking his ankle in week 8, still finished in the top 10 in the state in rushing yards.
HM: Connor Slomka, Pine-Richland; Saquon Barkley, Whitehall; Miles Sanders, Woodland Hills; Joe Unangst, Pennridge; Josh Adams, CB South; Lex Rosario, Delaware Valley
Wide Receivers
Michael Merhaut, Pine-Richland: 103 catches for 1,488 yards, 14 TDs
Ryan Hubley, Oxford: 93 catches for 1,480 yards, 19 TDs
Deonte Ramsey, Carlisle: 94 catches for 1,288 yards, 12 TDs
This trio of receivers became the first three players in state 4A history with over 90 catches, and each held the state single seaon receptions record at one point. Merhaut finished two yards shy of the 4A single season receiving yards record. Hubley set a single game TD catches record with 7. And Ramsey led a massive turnaround for Carlisle.
HM: Rafael Rodriguez, Benjamin Franklin; D'ondre Gastion, Pine-Richland; Kenny Yeboah, Parkland; Tim Vecchio, Penn-Trafford; Amechie Walker, Harrisburg; Jimmy Clark, Coatesville
Tight End
Cary Angeline, Downingtown East: 66 catches for 1,015 yards, 10 TDs
At 6'7, 230 pounds, Angeline is virtually uncoverable for high school defensive backs. He will be one of Pennsylvania's most heavily recruited players in the 2016 cycle.
HM: Amir Ealey, Coatesville; Charlie Hemcher, LaSalle; Kyle Walsh, Easton
Offensive Linemen
Jon Runyan, St. Joseph's Prep
Michael Fleming, Easton
Eric McAlister, Pittsburgh Central Catholic
Tyler Hudanick, Seneca Valley
John Kohley, Pine-Richland
The most difficult group to select and I tried to avoid just taking guys on reputation. Runyan help Prep maul their way to a state championhip. I watched Fleming week in and week out have a fabulous season paving the way for 4,000 rushing yards by Easton. Kohley both was a key offensive cog on the best offense in Pennsylvania. Hudanick, despite playing for 2-8 Seneca Valley, was a Pittsburgh Post Gazette All-22 selection and is one of the most highly regarded lineman in the state. And McAlister was the best offensive player on the WPIAL finalists.
HM: Forrest Myers, Easton; Chris Zerbe, Wilson West Lawn; Ed Mooney, St. Joseph's Prep; Alex Paulina, Canon MacMilan; Donovan McNelis, Penn-Trafford; Jacob Good, Pine-Richland; Austin O'Neill, Pennsbury
All Purpose
Shane Simpson, Easton: 233 carries for 2,124 yards, 33 TDs / 31 catches for 344 yards, 5 TDs / 41 total TDs / 3 INTs
D'Andre Swift, St. Joseph's Prep:: 137 for 1,045, 13 TDs / 33 catches for 495 yards, 6 TDs / 21 total TDs
Simpson led the state in total touchdowns with 41 and was a game breaker as a runner, receiver, return man, and defensive back. Swift took over the state championship game and is one of the best sophomores in America. The best offensive weapon on the best team in Pennsylvania.
Defensive Linemen
Jake Strain, St. Joseph's Prep
Amir Wallace, Parkland: 66 tackles, 15.5 sacks
Austin Rosa, Wilson West Lawn: 71 tackles, 10.5 sacks, 18 TFL, 2 FF, INT, 2 defensive TDs
Micah Parsons, Central Dauphin: 121 tackles, 18.5 sacks, 14 TFL, INT, FF, 3 blocked kicks
It was a really good year for Pennsylvania defensive linemen. The headliner in the freshman Parsons, who put up insane numbers for anybody, but particularly for a 14 or 15 year old playing varsity football. Wallace led District 11 and set a school record for sacks. Rosa was the conference DPOY for the state's stingiest defense. And Strain had another massive year for the state champs (just wish the PCL had defensive statistics somewhere so I could give him more credit).
HM: Shareef Miller, George Washington; Layne Skundrich, North Allegheny; Joe DuMond, St. Joseph's Prep; Kevin Givens, Altoona
Linebackers
Preston Saylor, Parkland: 120 tackles, 16 TFL, 4 sacks
Connor Ritter, Wilson West Lawn: 101 tackles, 17 TFL, 5.5 sacks, FF, INT
Steven McNeal, Central Dauphin: 140 tackles, 13 TFL, 4.5 sacks, 2 FF
Christian Randall-Posey, Penn Hills: 88 tackles, 13.5 TFL12.5 sacks
Joe Lieberman, Pine-Richland: 113 tackles, 12 TFL, 1 sack, 1 INT
Saylor led District 11's best defense in tackles and tackles for loss, and made their play of the year with his blocked punt against Easton. Ritter was the most productive player on Wilson's defensive, which gave Pine-Richland everything they could handle. McNeal was the Mid Penn DPOY and has the most tackles I've seen in 4A this year researching this team. Randall-Posey had huge sack numbers as a rush linebacker. And Lieberman (whose stats don't include WWL and SJP games) was the defensive engine for the state runner up.
HM: Stephen Pawling, Coatesville; Andy Davidson, Emmaus; Ryan Brady, LaSalle; Tim Spinelli, Cumberland Valley; Ike Schannauer, Wilson West Lawn; Thomas Johnson, St. Joseph's Prep
Defensive Backs
John Reid, St. Joseph's Prep: 2 INTs, 1 defensive TD / 36 catches for 699 yards, 12 TDs
Damar Hamlin, Pittsburgh Central Catholic: 45 tackles, 2 TFL, 1 sack, 4 INT, 3 defensive TDs
John Petrishen, Pittsburgh Central Catholic: 48 tackles, 2 INT / 4 return TDs
Jimmy Herron, LaSalle: 4 INT, 1 INT return TD / 71 catches for 931 yards, 12 TDs
Also a tough position to peg, but here the reputation guys are well deserving. Petrishen and Hamlin tag teamed in the best secondary in the state and helped carry an offensively limited but defensively nasty PCC team to the WPIAL finals. Reid is the best college prospect in the senior class and the best player on the best team. I needed to find a spot for Herron, who was an all PCL defensive back, and the most productive receiver in city history.
HM: John Fox, Wilson West Lawn; Jay Stocker, Coatesville; Yeedee Thaenrat, Father Judge; Jarey Elder, Parkland; Brendan Burnham, Pine-Richland;
Defensive All Purpose
Khaleke Hudson, McKeesport: 155 carries for 1,573 yards, 24 TDs / 28 tackles, 1 sack, 3 INT, FF
Jake Young, Freedom: 53 tackles, 3 FF, 2 INT, 3 defensive touchdowns / 43 catches for 581 yards, 5 TDs / two return TDs / Averaged 32 yards per punt.
Hudson led the WPIAL Quad-A class in rushing and will be one of the most highly recruited safties in Pennsylvania for 2016. Young did everything for the team with the biggest turnaround in the state (2-8 to 9-3). Had five defense/special teams touchdowns, led his team in receiving, returned kicks and punts, punted, and kicked extra points.
Jumbo Athletes
Trey Blanford, Penn-Trafford
Michal Menet, Exeter: 71 tackles, 6.5 sacks, 2 FF, 1 blocked kick
I added this category myself. Blanford is one of the best defensive ends in Pennsylvania and the best lineman on one of the most explosive offenses in Pennsylvania. Menet is a freak, a Rivals250 junior who is a nasty blocker and one of the most disruptive defensive linemen in the state.
Kick Specialist
Jake Bissell, Parkland: 8-12 FG, long of 43, 58 XP, 39 touchbacks, 38.5 yards per punt.
Huge special teams weapon for the state quarterfinalists. Able to flip the field as a punter adding to Parkland's defensive weapons. Expanded the red zone with his range and a touchback machine in the return game.