PA Dynasty Ratings

[new2pa]

1. SJP
2. P-R
3. Southern Columbia
4. Harrisburg
5. PCC

 

[Relayer]

How can a team be considered a dynasty if they have never won a state championship? Then again, it's Max Preps.

 

[northalleghenytiger]

Southern Columbia certainly is the most dominant dynasty in PA, even if they are 2A. They should be #1

 

[Stalker]

Whoa nelly! Thats a slap in the face to the real Harrisburg power, Bishop McDevitt with 2 titles and 4 runner-up Silver Medals.
** 5 finals appearances since 2010. Not bad.
** Heard Clairton had some teams that were ok. Maybe not.
**** Back to the game. GO AIR FORCE....Hell from Above.

 

[new2pa]

I think it’s last 5 years only.

 

[Hausmann1978]

View embedded media

1. SJP
2. P-R
3. Southern Columbia
4. Harrisburg
5. PCC

I'd put bishop guilfoyle or allquippa over pcc and Harrisburg.

 

[Stalker]

I think it’s last 5 years only.

That would make a little more sense 'New', making it a mislabel. I mean, a Dynasty in 5 Years !*?

 

[RCH13co18]

“FROM THE PAST FIVE FOOTBALL SEASONS”

 

[Stalker]

FROM THE PAST FIVE FOOTBALL SEASONS”

I see that now but unless they redefined the word 'dynasty' it's a real mislead with the caption "Dynasty Ratings." Takes a bit more than 5 years to earn that title....!!!!....teams like SJP and SCA. Now you're talking.
Heck of a run in 5 years for Harrisburg for sure. But dynasty? Especially in a town with Bishop McDevitt having gold and silver trophies the last 5 years, a won-loss of 51-9 and a stepped-up schedule playing Imhotep and LaSalle the last 2-years.

 

[northalleghenytiger]

Dynasty means 3 titles in 4 years. The only dynasty’s in PA are Southern Columbia and St Joes

 

[new2pa]

17
20
22
Don’t count?

 

[northalleghenytiger]

17
20
22
Don’t count?

PR is a Wpial dynasty for sure

 

[Stalker]

Dynasty means 3 titles in 4 years. The only dynasty’s in PA are Southern Columbia and St Joes

Where did you hear that? 3-4 years is a run....not a dynasty.

 

[northalleghenytiger]

Where did you hear that? 3-4 years is a run....not a dynasty.

Most professional leagues consider 3 titles in 4 years a dynasty.

 

[Stalker]

Most professional leagues consider 3 titles in 4 years a dynasty.

Makes some sense at the professional level per transient/fluid nature of pro sports but not HS FB in my view. Thanks NA.

 

[2020sports]

top 3 are legit, anyone who questions that, is stupid

cool, that we get a "national view"