2020: You got me thinking and I had to call a ton of people, but here the list of P-R seniors that played football (or could have played football and chose a different sport - aka Spencer.) I don't have a lot of contacts before 2014, so that may be spotty. You can see why the 2014 (18), 2017 (15) and 2020 (19) teams were so good. A TON of kids that were Juniors and Seniors (and a few Sophomores) that got the opportunity to play at a high level. I don't really think any of the other teams stack up close to those three in terms of talent and probably competition.
2010 Seniors (2) (FBS: 0 FCS: 2 D2: 0 D3: 0 )
Andy Borgen, QB: VMI
Tommy Berexa, WR: Duquesne
2011 Seniors(3) (FBS: 1 FCS: D2: D3: 2 )
Austin Whipple Post-Grad/PSU/UMass
Steve Szelong, Muhlenberg
Ben Balish, John Carroll
2012 Seniors (9) (FBS: 3 FCS: 1 D2: 3 D3: 2 )
Nick Elms, Pitt
Luke Merhaut, Clarion
Brock Baranowski, Penn State
Kevin Rader, Youngstown
Nick Berus, UMass
CJ Jackson, IUP
Patrick Kline, CalU
TJ Muzzonigro, Tufts
Michael Keffer, Wyanesburg
2013 Seniors (1) (FBS: 0 FCS: 0 D2: 0 D3: 0 )
Chris Szelong, John Caroll
2014 Seniors (10) (FBS: 3 FCS: 1 D2: 3 D3: 2 JuCo: 1 Other: 1 )
Ben DiNucci, Pitt
Diondre Gaston, Juco
Matt Zoeller, Clarion
Jake Goode, Clarion
John Kohley, Dayton
Connor Slomka, Army
Brenden Burnham (Maryland / Wrestling)
Earnest William, Slippery Rock
Joe English, Kent State
Luke Everett, Juniata
2015 Seniors (8) (FBS: 1 FCS: 3 D2: 2 D3: 2 )
Anthony Battaglia, Army
Matt Hamspon, Princeton
Jim Willard, Slippery Rock
Joey Joy, Westminster
Jimmy Graf, Westminster
Don Bryant, Mercyhurst
Tom Jurkovec, Duquesne
Jacob Gill, Duquesne
2016 Seniors (5) (FBS: 3 FCS: 2 D2: 0 D3: 0 )
Ryan Duran, Army
Neiman Novitski, Kent State
Tanner Douglass, Lamar
Mark Weideman, Duquesne
Grant Carrigan, Pitt
2017 Seniors (6) (FBS: 1 FCS: 1 D2: 1 D3: 1 JuCo: 1 Other: 1)
Phil Jurkovec, ND
Ray Falcone, Lehigh
Kenny White, JuCo
Jordan Crawford, Slippery Rock
Dawson Golts (Highpoint, LAX)
Vito Orsini, Marietta
2018 Seniors (9) (FBS: 3 FCS: 3 D2: 0 D3: 3 )
Andrew Kristofic, ND
Mike Katic, Indiana
Tyler King, Navy
Mike Dorundo, Duquesne
Anthony Cerminara, Dayton
Shayne Cafardi, Allegheny
Ben McGregor, Westminster
Dylan Stenson, Youngstown
Merrick Miller, Denison
2019 Seniors (6) (FBS: 1 FCS: 3 D2: 1 D3: 1 )
Seth Bolin, Duquesne
Levi Wentz, Old Dominion
Nevin Novitski, Mercyhurst
Chance Boyd, John Carrol
Trent Miller, Valparaiso
Ethan O’Neil, Duquesne
2020 Seniors (11) (FBS: 4 FCS: 3 D2: 0 D3: 3 Other: 1 )
Harrison Hayes, Liberty
Miguel Jackson, Charlotte
Luke Miller, Kent State
Eli Jochem, Indiana
Cole Spencer (Penn, Wrestling)
Sam Neill, Duquesne
Charlie Mill, Elon
Jordan Burns, Westminster
Roman Dunlap, W & J
Zach Waryanka, John Carrol
John Swisher, Duquesne
2021 Seniors (6) (FBS: 2 FCS: 3 D2: 1 D3: 0 )
Jeremiah Hasley, Duke
Cole Boyd, Marist
Alex Gochis, Duquesne
Connor Lenz, Duquesne
Jalen Klemm, Kansas State
Jacob Domer, Clarion
2022 Seniors (4) (FBS: 1 FCS: 2 D2: 1 D3: )
Jacob Beam (Best Offer: Marshall)
Max Heckert (Best Offer: Marist)
Ryan Palmeiri (Best Offer: None)
Isaiah Kerns (Best Offer: Clarion)
Andrew Mellis (Best Offer: Dayton)
Brady Carrigan (Best Offer: None)
John Rottinghaus (Best Offer: None)
2023 Seniors (1) (FBS: 1 FCS: 0 D2: 0 D3: )
Ryan Cory (Best Offer: Oregon)