The big thing with him trying to do both is weight. He’ll wrestle 197, but if you’re that sized at running back, you better run a 4.3 (at least if you want to play at Michigan, Lehigh is a little different), but bulking to a fullback/H-back takes him out of range to make the cut. Again, all of my indications are he’d be a fabulous Patriot League football player, but he’s national caliber as a wrestle. We’ll see what happens trying to do both. He’s definitely a wresting background guy - his dad Mike was a 3x state champ at Mount Carmel and was a massive recruit for Buckner (that took the whole program down in an NCAA scandal).
Doing both is definitely a challenge. Josh Hokit at Fresno State All American’d at 197 after playing fullback and scoring 9 touchdowns for their football team, but that’s the only example I can remember. From up our way, Ryan Hluschak tried to do both at Lehigh, ended up transferring to Drexel to just wrestle and AA’d, but part of that was cutting down to 157 instead of his football playing weight. Jason Groller did both at Shippensburg and was a D2 AA, but that’s a lot different than Lehigh. Jan Johnson got asked to help the wresting team out at Penn State after some injuries, so probably not a fair comparison, but he struggled wrestling heavyweight after playing linebacker in the Big Ten, that’s probably the best analogue to what Garcia was trying to do.